Three teenage Coptic students
have been sentenced to five years in jail, while a fourth was sentenced to an
indefinite detention period in a juvenile detention facility after being
convicted on charges of blasphemy, insulting Islam, and fomenting sectarian
strife on 25 February.
The five-year sentences handed
down to the teenagers are the maximum penalty for these charges. According to
the Egyptian Initiative for Personal Rights (EIPR), a request by
their lawyer for the video to be screened in court was refused once again. The
teenage students are currently out on bail and their lawyer plans to launch an
appeal against the sentences.
Mueller Atef Edward, Amjad Hanna,
Alber Ashraf Hanna and Clinton Majidi Yousif, from Bani Mazar in the Minya
province of Upper Egypt, were charged after a mobile p one video recorded in early
2015 by their teacher, Mr Gad Yousif Younan, depicting them conducting a mock
beheading, became public after the teacher lost his phone memory card. Mr Gad
Yousif Younan has already been sentenced to three years in prison for
“Insulting Islam.”
The boys and their teacher were
arrested in April 2015, following a period of increased sectarian tension in
their local community of Nassiriya, which is located approximately 250km south
of Cairo. Their lawyer has raised concerns
that charges were brought against them without the court having viewed the
32-second video and on the basis of biased police reports and speculation among
the local community that the boys were mocking Muslim prayer rites.
Indictments involving charges of
“contempt of religion”, “insulting Islam” and “blasphemy” are on the increase
in Egypt. Christian Solidarity Worldwide (CSW) recently reported on the cases
of researcher and TV presenter Islam
al-Beheiry and secular writer Fatima
Naaot, both of whom were convicted of “contempt of religion” in recent
months.
These charges are articulated in
Article 98 of the Egyptian Penal Code, which is vaguely worded and open to
broad interpretation. It states that “exploiting religion in spreading, either
by words, in writing, or in any other means, extreme ideas for the purposes of
inciting strife, ridiculing or insulting [the Abrahamic faiths] or a sect
following it, or damaging national unity”, is punishable by prison sentences of
between six months and five years, and fines of 500-1,000 Egyptian Pounds
(approximately £42-£84).
CSW’s
Chief Executive Mervyn Thomas said, “We are deeply shocked that these teenagers
have been given the maximum sentence under the law. While the video was
undoubtedly ill-advised, these charges were excessive and should never have
been brought. Moreover, the manner in which this trial was conducted, and the
court’s failure to view primary evidence prior to passing judgement despite its
ready availability, violates due process. CSW urges the Egyptian authorities to
grant clemency to these boys and their teacher and to stem the worrying rise of
blasphemy and contempt of religion charges by amending Article 98 of the penal
code, using the Rabat Plan of Action as a guideline.”